| |
INTRODUCTION
Irritant dermatitis includes several inflammatory reactions,
which follow non-immunological damage to the skin. This may be
the result of an a/c toxic insult to the skin, or due to the
result of repeated and cumulative damage from both physical and
chemical agents. Irritant dermatitis is also called as the
irritant contact dermatitis (ICD).Irritant dermatitis is not a
uniform entity of disease each irritant exerts its particular
noxious effects on the skin36
Dermatitis is a term used to denote a polymorphic pattern of
inflammation of skin characterized by erythema, edema,
vesiculation, oozing, crusting, papules scaling and
lichenification.
Contact
dermatitis includes:
1) Irritant contact dermatitis
2) Allergic contact dermatitis
3) Phototoxic, photoallergic and light aggravated contact
dermatitis
4) Immediate type contact dermatitis
Irritant contact
dermatitis is due to non-immunologocial damage to skin.
Allergic contact dermatitis leads to type IV hypersensitivity
and cell mediated immune damage to skin. Here the offending
agent is a hapten and it combines with skin protein to become
antigenic.
Photo dermatitis involves immunological and non-immunological
damage to skin due to exposure to sun.
Immediate type contact dermatitis also leads to both
immunological and non-immunological damage to skin.
Irritant contact dermatitis due to soap detergents commonly
affects housewives and cleaners who immerse their hands in water
and detergent. It is presumably due to the combination of
asteatosis, exposure to mild irritants such as soap and mild
trauma. e.g. wringing out dishcloths.
ICD is one of the greatest health problems. This problem is on
the increase as the new brands of soaps and detergents marketed
are having many additives like perfumes, antibacterial,
antimicrobials coloring agents etc which act as sensitizers.
Hygienic measurements like avoidance of soaps and detergents is
not wholly possible for many owing to the cultural and socio
economic conditions. Modern school medication offers sudden
relief for all the symptoms but there is resurgence of the
symptoms on discontinuing the meditation and when the patient is
again, exposed to soaps and detergents. Many patients are not
able to continue modern medicines because of their disastrous
side effects and also due to economic reasons. Homoeopathic
medicines becomes their only hope and aid, as the cure affected
is rapid, gentle and permanent without any deleterious effect.
Homoeopathy has for its foundation, solid concrete facts
united by great natural principles. The practical demonstration
of Homoeopathy is committed to its personal representatives
whose ability, acquired technical proficiency and logical
consistency can bring to the system a scientific stand and
success. Master Hahnemann through years of closest observation
and careful experimentation has constructed this system on the
basic principles of similia similibus curenter, minimum dose and
single remedy. The structure is further raised on the
fundamental principles, which are consistent with the universal
laws and the framework is being furnished by years of study and
experiments by the younger generations of homoeopaths. A humble
effort in this regard is made on attempting to study the
efficacy of homoeopathic medicines in the management of irritant
contact dermatitis due to soap and detergents with the help of
experienced hands in homoeopathy.
It is not ICD as such, which is the object of our consideration,
but the man affected with ICD. The man is affected in the
internals and it is the manifestation of internals, which
present as ICD. It should be given due thought that, all people
exposed to the noxious effects of soaps and detergents are not
having the disease manifestation. Why is some people peculiarly
disposed to have this disease? What brought forth the disease
manifestation? What is behind the cell disturbance or life
perversion in the affected part?
Hahnemann through his diligent study and 12 years of
accurate observation and experimentation came to the fact that
the ostensible disease manifestation was a mere fragment of a
much more deep seated primitive evil, which he called miasm.
Thus miasms were discovered to be the unknown primitive malady,
which caused all ailments and symptoms. Understanding miasm
involves understanding sum total of all the sufferings of the
patient, which in turn involves a comprehensive study of the
etiology, symptamatology, pathology and life situation of the
patient. So in the succeeding pages, the subject matter is dealt
with, due stress on etiology, symptamatology, pathology,
diagnostic criteria’s and miasmatic interpretation.
AIMS OF THE STUDY
To ascertain the effectiveness of homoeopathic medicines in
the management of irritant contact dermatitis due to soap and
detergents. There are many effective homoeopathic medicines for
this malady but until now nobody has undertaken a scientific
study in this manner based on statistical data.
In addition to this special attention is given to
1) Trace out the prominent miasm behind the malady.
2) Relation of irritant contact dermatitis to the socio-economic
status of the patient.
3) Whether medicinal management is effective, if so to what
extent.
4) Are there cases beyond the scope of homoeopathic treatment?
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Irritant contact dermatitis is caused by direct chemical or
physical damage to the skin. It is not a uniform entity of
disease ,each irritant exerts its particular noxious effects on
the skin and each occupation has its special risk of substance
and mode of physical contact .Everyone is susceptible to the
development of an irritant contact dermatitis if exposed to an
irritant (toxic) agent is sufficient quantity. It occurs
particularly where the stratum corneum is thinnest. Hence, it is
often seen in the finger webs and back of the hands rather than
the palms.
Examples of common irritants 50
* Wet work * Soluble coolants
* Solvents * Vegetable juices
* Detergents * Wet cement
With all of above the skin may hit at several target sites
There are two
main types of irritant contact dermatitis acute and chronic.
The acute form occurs after exposure to an agent or agents
causes an early impairment in the function of the stratum
corneum and an acute inflammatory reaction (Fig 1:1) .The
chronic form follows repeated exposure to the same or different
factors causing cumulative damage until an inflammatory reaction
ensues that persists even after further exposure is stopped.
Thus clinically apparent disease occurs only after a subliminal
damaging effect has occurred. (Fig 1:2). Chronic irritant
dermatitis is mostly due to the summation of various adverse
factors. These factors are together known as the ‘loading
factors’.(Fig1:3) . These include individual predisposition,
atopics, impaired resistance, skin temperature, repair capacity,
high baseline trans epidermal water loss, scratching, rubbing
etc. Many of these are not strong enough to cause irritant
dermatitis as such but when taken together they are enough to
weaken the skin and develop irritant contact dermatitis. These
minor irritants may also act as perpetuating factors once the
dermatitis has become established .Repeated exposure to some of
the milder irritants may in course of time produce a hardening
effect . This process makes the skin more resistant to the
irritant effect of the given substance.35
Anatomy –
Microstructure of skin
The epidermis is a compound tissue consisting mainly of a
continuously self-replacing stratified keratinized squamous
epithelium. The chief cells of epidermis are the keratinocytes,
there are other cells called melanocytes, Langerhan cells and
lymphocytes. Sensory nerve endings are also sparsely present in
the epidermis. Epidermis serves as an important barrier to the
loss of water and other substances through the body surface and
to their permeation from without. Experiments measuring
diffusion of water from the exterior show that the entire
stratum corneum provides an effective though not complete
barrier. The water barrier is composed of intercellular glyco
lipid sheets or lamelloe derived from the lamellar granules of
the stratum granulosum.44
Development
Embryonic skin consists of a single layer of ectodermal
cells overlying a mesenchyme. From this surface epidermis and
its appendages and dermis are formed. Surface ectoderm gives
rise to the keratinizing general surface epidermis and its
appendages, the pilosebaceous units, sudoriferous glands and
nails. Some of the ectodermal cells become the keratinocytes.
Non-keratinocytic cells of the epidermis are immigrant cells of
different developmental origin. The dermis is composed of
irregular connective tissue. The connective tissue is developed
from the mesenchyme.
Histology of normal skin
The cells produced by mitosis in the germinal layer adjacent
to the dermis undergo maturational changes concerned with the
production of keratin. The outer keratinised layer is shed
continuously and is replaced by the progressive movement and
maturation of cells from the germinal layer. The rate of mitosis
in the germinal layer generally equals the rate of desquamation
of keratin from the outer surface. This process of maturation of
basal cells through to desquamation takes approximately 28 days
in humans.
The phases of this dynamic process are represented in five
morphological layers.
1) The stratum germinativum or stratum basale B: is the
germinal layer of the epidermis. This layer is also sometimes
referred to as stratum malpighii
2) The stratum spinosum or prickle cell layer S: So named for
the prickly appearance of the cells at high magnification. This
layer contains cells, which are in the process of growth and
early keratin synthesis.
3) The stratum granulosum or granular layer G: is characterized
by the presence of granules within the cells, which contribute
to the process of keratinisation.
4) The stratum lucidum L: is only present in extremely thick
skin and appears as a homogeneous layer between the stratum
granulosum and the keratinised layer.
5) The stratum corneum or cornified layer C: consists of
flattened, fused cell remnants composed mainly of fibrous
protein keratin.
Histology of
epidermis
The epidermis is a non vascular stratified epithelium of
ectodermic origin the deeper layer five layers which consists is
living, it consists of several strata of polyhedral cells
resting on a single stratum of columnar (basal) cells. The
superficial layer, the horny layer or stratum corneum, is dead,
it consists of several strata of dry, flattened, scaly cells
perpetually being rubbed away and are perpetually being replaced
by cells of the germinative layer.
Irritant dermatitis due to detergents and soaps
SYNONYMS
House wife’s eczema, asteatotic hand eczema, wears and tears
dermatitis and traumiterative dermatitis.
DEFINITION
Is a chronic inflammatory reaction of the skin, to a series
of repetitive and damaging insults which include both chemical
irritants and harmful physical factors such as friction, micro
trauma, low humidity, heat, cold, solvents, degreasing agents
such as soap and detergent and desiccant effects of water.
Irritant contact dermatitis due to soap clinically manifests as
a spectrum of disease ranging from a little dryness, redness or
chapping (irritant reactions) through various types of
eczematous dermatitis. It mostly affects thin exposed skin,
mostly on the back of hands, webs of fingers etc. Housewife’s
dermatitis remains confined to hands.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Irritant contact dermatitis accounts for 4-7 % of all
dermatological consultations. It accounts for almost all
reported cases of occupational diseases. Hand eczema affects
more than 2% of all the populations. Over 20% of females will
suffer from hand eczema at some stage of their life.
INCIDENCE AND
PREVALENCE
The disease exits in all countries, it is more prevalent in
some places than in others. Prevalence varies from country to
country. Measures like wearing proctective gloves are found to
reduce the incidence of irritant contact dermatitis.
SEASONAL CHANGE
Chapping of skin during winter predispose to irritant
contact dermatitis and increases its incidence. Other factor,
which increases the incidence of irritant contact dermatitis,
includes technical factors like concentration of irritant,
vehicle, exposure time etc.
AGE
Age has little influence on capacity for sensitization.
Occupational sensitization may occur only after decades of
contact with a senitizer. Sensitivities may also fade with time
but this is probably due more to lack of exposure rather than
age per se. The inflammatory response is however diminished in
elderly patients. Young, adults are more likely to have irritant
dermatitis.
SEX
As name suggests irritant dermatitis due to soap is more
common in females so it is also called housewife’s dermatitis
.HORMONES
Pregnancy may either improve or flare up contact dermatitis.
Irritant dermatitis may flare up premenustrually. No systemic
studies on the capacity for sensitization as related to
menstrual period have yet been performed.
CONSTITUTIONAL
AND GENETIC FACTORS
Development of ICD presupposes an individual susceptibility.
In humans susceptibility does not follow mendelian inheritance.
It is found that atopics have an increased risk of developing
irritant hand eczema.
INTERACTION OF CONSTITUTIONAL, CUMULATIVE AND ALLERGIC
FACTORS
In many cases of hand dermatitis, constitutional irritant
and allergic factors will co-exit. A hand eczema that starts as
contact dermatitis may continue as an apparently constitutional,
post insult form of eczema. Associated detergents may promote
sensitization and lower the threshold for the elicitation of
allergic contact dermatitis. It is however, often very difficult
to verify a suspicion of allergic sensitivity to an ingredient
in soap or detergent unless all ingredients in soap or
detergents are tested separately and at appropriate
concentrations. Allergic factors may play a part in the
persistence and reactivations of some cases of irritant or
constitutional hand eczema.
In case of soaps and detergents, soap and detergent part acts as
the irritant but the antimicrobials, the antibacterials,
formaldehyde, perfumes etc. added during the manufacture acts as
the sensitizers. Further if the patient uses rubber gloves it
adds to the sensitivity .
ENVIRONMENTAL
FACTOR
Low ambient humidity is the single most important factor as
far as the water content of the stratum corneum is concerned.
Although the effect of temperature and humidity are to some
degree interrelated , cold alone will reduce the water content
and plasticity of stratum corneum and lead to cracking of the
corneum (horny layer).
Low temperature
and humidity reduces the water content of stratum corneum and
leads to cracking of stratum corneum. Simultaneous exposure to
these factors may maintain a dermatosis or cause transition from
a simple chapping to a more eczematous dermatitis.
Occlusion promotes percutaneous absorption and may facilitate
skin irritation and enhance the effect of irritants to which an
individual has previously been exposed. Increasing the water
content of stratum corneum by occlusion can enhance percutaneous
absorption of certain substances many times. It is of practical
importance that rubber and plastic gloves, waterproof adhesives
and the natural folds of skin provide such occlusion. Soft
paraffin by itself has an occlusive effect.
Alkaline
solutions have a deleterious action on the horny layer and
promote percutaneous absorption. Cross-links in the Keratin are
broken and water can penetrate into the fibrils and cause the
swelling of horny layer. If reducing substances are present the
damages is still greater. Irritants damage the stratum corneum
directly or indirectly by damaging the basal layer of epidermis
or otherwise by inducing abnormal keratinization. Damage in
either form will lead to increased skin permeability.
Percutaneous absorption is also facilitated by inflammatory
changes in the epidermis. Thus an irritant contact dermatitis
can promote penetration of allergens and conversely an allergic
contact dermatitis the penetration of irritants.
Thus it could be seen that an irritants like detergents and
soaps will produce cell damage if applied for sufficient time in
sufficient concentrations. Immunological process are not
involved and dermatitis occurs without prior sensitization.
Irritants penetrate skin and alter skin cells. Dermatitis arises
when the repair capacity of skin is exhausted and when the
penetration of chemicals excites and inflammatory response. The
detergents causes damage by gradually exhausting the horny
layer, denaturing the keratin, removing stratum corneum lipids
and altering the water holding capacity of skin. This eventually
leads to damage to the cells of the epidermis.
Pathophysiology
Irritant contact dermatitis includes several inflammatory
reaction patterns, which follow non-immunological (usually
chemical) damage to the skin. This may be the result of an acute
toxic insult to the skin or due to repeated and cumulative
damage both physical and chemical. Detergents and soap may cause
both conventional irritant and non-immunological reaction
pattern, which vary from individual to individual depending upon
the application site, nature of chemical applied and the degree
of damage to the skin.
The skin provides
the first and most important line of defense against exogenous
noxious agents and this is one of its primary physiological
functions. This defense is however, far from perfect as many
substances penetrate readily into and through the epidermis even
when it is intact. The surface film is the first line of defense.
It is composed of sebum emulsified with sweat and break down
products from the horny layer. The buffer capacity of the
surface film varies considerably from one body region to
another, but in reality it has negligible influence on
percutaneous absorption and on the barrier function of skin. The
barrier function of the skin mostly resides in the stratum
corneum. Damage to or a reduction in strateum corneum is
therefore normally followed by an increase in the percutaneous
absorption and in trans epidermal water loss. (The strateum
corneum, having a predominantly lipid intercellular composition
is more susceptible to lipid soluble irritants). The main
barrier to water transport through the skin is attributed to
these lipids and when the lipids of the strateum corneum are
removed by solvents, water transport rates through the skin will
increase.
The flexibility
and cohesion of the horny layer depend mostly on its water
content. The cell walls of the keratin layer constitute a lipid
containing, semi-permeable membrane that encloses the water
soluble substances as in an envelope. If the water holding
substances are reduced, the water content of the stratum corneum
decreases and superficial cracks develop. This collection of in
situ water holding substances is referred to as natural
moisturing factor. The principle components include sodium
pyrrolidone, carboxylic acid, sodium calcium lactate, amino
acids, urea and a sugar protein complex. These substances bind
three – four times their own weight of water. Following the
removal of cell wall lipids by exposure to a solvent, subsequent
immersion in water for 2 minutes will remove as many of the
water-soluble substances from the keratin layer as a 2-hour
immersion in water.
A detergent effects the combined removal of both lipids and
water holding substances and thus predisposes to chapping.
Washing with a slush of ice and acetone has a three – fold
effect of removing both lipids and water holding substances
Most cases of
housewife’s eczema are ICD resulting from repeated skin exposure
to low-grade cutaneous irritants, particularly soaps, water and
detergents. It is the cumulative ICD from repeated mild skin
irritation from soap and water. For e.g. hand washing frequency
of more than 35 times per day was associated strongly with
occupational hand dermatitis in intensive care worker’s .
The pathogenesis
of ICD involves resident epidermal cells, dermal fibroblasts,
endothelial cells and various leukocytes interacting with each
other under the control of a network of cytokines and lipid
mediators. Keratinocytes play an important role in the
irritation and perpetuation of skin inflammatory reactions
through the release of and response to cytokines. Resting
keratinocytes produce some cytokines constitutively. Irritants
can induce epidermal keratinocytes to release inflammatory
cytokines (interleukin 1, TNKα), chemotactic cytokines (IL8,
IL10), growth promoting cytokines (IL - 6, IL – 7, IL – 15
granuloyte – macrophage colony stimulating factor, transforming
growth factor α) and cytokines regulating humoral versus
cellular immunity (IL – 10, IL – 12, IL – 18). Intercellular
adhesion molecules 1 promote the infiltration of leukocytes into
the epidermis causing a cutaneous inflammatory reaction.
Significantly increased number of dividing keratinocytes is
present 48 and 96 hours after exposure to an ionic emulsifying
agent like soaps and detergents.
Soap if kept in contact with skin for a long time causes
irritant dermatitis . No immunological mechanism take part in
this reaction.43
Next Page
|
|