Date posted: April 2, 2012

Dr Saji K   

The repetition may be
1. In the same chapter in another manner
(a) with the same medicines and
(i) same grading.
(ii) different grading.
(b) with different medicines.

2. In a different chapter in another manner
(a) with the same medicines. and
(i) same grading.
(ii) different grading.
(b) with different medicines.

Examples from chapter mind :
I. In the same chapter,with the same medicine and same grading but in another manner.
Mind : Activity,fruitless.: Stann.
Mind : Busy,fruitlessly. : Stann.

Mind : Aversion,relegious to the opposite sex : Lyc.,Puls(2).,Sulph.
Mind : Relegious,horror of the opposite sex :Lyc.,Puls(2).,Sulph.

Mind : Children,flies from his own : Lyc.
Mind : Estranged,flies from her own children : Lyc.
Mind : Forsakes his own children : Lyc.
Mind : Escape,from her family,children : Lyc.

Mind : Delerium,wraps up in fur during summer : Hyos.
Mind : Fur,wraps up in summer : Hyos.
Mind : Roving,wrapped in fur in the summer : Hyos.

Mind : Forgetful, sleep during, he remembers all he had forgotten : Calad.,Selen.
Mind : Forgotten,things comes to mind in sleep : Calad,Selen.

II. In the same chapter,with same medicines,but in different grading.
Mind : Death,presentiment of,predicts the time : Acon(2)., Arg.n(2).
Mind : Prophesying,predicts the time of death :Acon(3)., Arg.n.
Mind : Fear,death of,predicts the time : Acon(3),Arg.n(2)

Mind : Delusions,beautiful,rags seems even : Sulph(2).
Mind : Imbecility,old rags as fine as silk : Sulph(3).
Mind : Delusions,old rags are as fine as silk : Sulph(3)

Mind : Reveals,secrets in sleep : Am.c., Ars(2).
Mind : Talking,sleep in,reveals secrets in sleep : Am.c., Ars.

III. In the same chapter with different medicines.
Mind : Answers,stupor returns quickly after : Arn(2).,Bapt., Hyos(3)., Plb.
Mind : Unconsciouness,answers correctly when spoken to but delerium and unconsciousness returns at once. :
Arn(2)., Bapt(2)., Hyos(2).

Mind : Confusion,loses his way in well known streets :Glon(3).,Merc(2).,Nux.m(2).,Petr(2).,Ran.b.,Thuj.
Mind : Forgetful,streets of well known :Glon(3).,Petr(2).,Nux.m(2).
Mind : Recognise does not,well known streets :Cann.i.,Glon(3).,Lach.,Nux.m(3).,Petr(3).

Mind : Antics,plays.: Bell(2),Cupr,Hyos(3),Lact,Op,Merc,phos,Plb,Stram.
Mind : Delerium,antics plays : Bell,Cupr,Hyos(3),Lact,Op,Phos,Plb,Stram.

Mind : Irritability, sends the doctor home,says he is not sick. : Apis.,Arn(3).,Cham(3).
Mind : Well,says he is,when very sick : Apis(2),Arn(3),Ars,Cinnb,Hyos,Kreos,Merc,Puls.
Mind : Obstinate, declares there is nothing the matter with him : Apis.,Arn(3).

Mind : Persists in nothing : Lac.c., Lach., Plan.
Mind : Undertakes many things,perseveres in nothing :Acon(2),Lac.c(2),Lach(2),Plan.

Mind : Fanaticism : Caust,Rob,Selen,Sulph,Thuj(2).
Mind : Relegious,fanaticism : Rob,Selen,Sulph,Thuj.

Mind : Indifference,exposure of her person :Hyos(2),Phos(2),Phyt(2),Sec(2), Stram,Verat.
Mind : Shameless,exposes the person : Hyos(3),Phos(2),Phyt,Sec(2),Tarent(2).

Mind : Pull,desires to pull ones hair : Bell(3).,Lach., Lil.t(2).,Tarent.
Mind : Tears,hair,her : Bell(2).,Lil.t(2).,Tarent.

Mind : Absent minded,starts when spoken to :
Mind : Starting,spoken to when :, Sulph.

Mind : Hatred,women of : Puls(2).
Mind : Women,aversion to : Am.c,Bapt,Dios(2),Lach(2),Nat.m.,puls(2),Sulph.

IV. In a different chapter, with the same medicine and same grading.
Mind : Striking,knocking his head against wall : Apis,Ars,Bell,Con,Hyos,Mag.c,Mill,Rhus.t.
Head : Knocks head against things : Apis,Ars,Bell,Con,Hyos,Mag.c,Mill,Rhus.t.

V. In different chapters with different medicines.
Mind : Light,desire for : Acon(2),Am.m(2),Bell(3),Calc(2),Gels(3),Lac.c,Nat.m,Ruta,Stram(3),Valer.
Eye : Photomania : Acon(2), Am.m, Bell(3), Calc, Gels(3),Lac.c(2),Ruta,Stram(3),Valer.

Mind : Laughing,sardonic. : Bell(3),Caust(2),Colch(2),Con,Hyos(2),Ign,Nux.m,Oena(2),Plb,

Face : Risus sardonicus. : Medicines and grading same as above with the omission of Tarent. in the list.

Mind : Speech,unintelligible :Acon,Ars,Bell(3),Euph,Hyos(3),Lyc,Merc(2),Naja,Nux.v,, Sec(2), Sil,Stram(3),Tab.

Mouth: Speech,unintelligible :Ars,Art.v,Asaf, Bell(2), Bufo,

Examples from chapter vertigo :
I. In the same chapter with different medicines.
Vertigo : Crossing,running water :Ang(2),Arg.m(2),Brom,Ferr,Sulph.
Vertigo : Water,crssing running :Ang,Arg.m(2),Bell(2),Brom,Ferr(2),Hyos(2),Stram,Sulph(2).

II. In different chapters with different medicines.
Vertigo : Vision obscuration of, with.( large rubric )It contains 60 medicines.
Vision : Dim,vertigo, during ( large rubric )It contains 58 medicines.

Vertigo : Vomiting with : ( large rubric, 33 medicines )
Stomach : Vomiting, vertigo,during : ( large rubric, 31 medicines )

Examples from head chapter ;
I. In different chapters with different medicines :
Head : Perspiration,except the head :Bell,Merc,Nux.v,Rhus.t(3),Samb(3),Sep(2),Thuj.
Perspiration : Head,general sweat,except the Bell(2),Merc,Nux.v,Rhust.t(3),Samb(3),Sec(2),Sep(2),Thuj(3)

EYE  : Photomania :

I In the same chapter with the same medicines.
Ear : Tumours,wen,behind ears : Merc.i.r., Verb.
Ear : Wen,behind ear : Merc.i.r., Verb.

I In the same chapter with different medicines.

Nose : Epistaxis,amenorrhoea,with : Bry(2).,Cact(2).,Con.,Ham.,Lach.,Ol.j.,Phos(2).,Puls(2).
Nose : Epistaxis,vicarious:Bry(2),Ham(3),Lach(2),Phos(3),Puls(2).

II In different chapters, with the same medicines, but different grading.

Nose : Discolouration,yellow saddle. :, Sanic., Sep(3).
Face : Saddle,acros the nose :, Sanic., Sep(3).

III. In different chapters, with different medicines.
Nose : Liquids, come out through the nose on attempting to swallow. : 30 medicines. Arum.t.,Lac.c.,Lach.,and Lyc.
are the first grade medicines.

Throat: Liquids,taken are forced into nose.: 28 medicines. (Gels and Hyos seem missing.) in the second grade.
Others same.

Face :
I In the same chapter with the same medicines,in the same grading.
Face : Bloated,between the eyes. : Lyc.
Face : Swelling,eyes,between : Lyc.

II In different chapters with different medicines.
Face : Convulsions,beginning in face : Absin,Bufo(2),Cina,Dulc,Hyos,Ign,Sant,Sec(2).
Generalities : Convulsions,Begins in the face : Absin,Buf(2),Cina,Dulc,Hyos(2),Ign(2),Lach(2),Sant,Sec(2).

Face : Risus sardonicus.
Face : Saddle across the nose.

Throat :
I in the same chapter,with the same medicines,in the same grading.
Throat : Swallowing,difficult,drink must,inorder to swallow : Bell(2),Cact(2),Cur,Elaps,Kali.c,Nat.c(2),Nat.m.
Throat : Swallowing,impeded,must drink at every mouthful to wash down the food : Bell(2),Cact(2),Cur, Elaps,Kali.c,Nat.c(2),Nat.m.

Throat : Swallowing,fluids only,can swallow, but solid food gags : Bapt(2),Bar.c,Crot.c(2),Crot.h(2),Plb(2),Sil(2).
Throat : Swallowing,impeded,liquids only can swallow,least food gags. : Bapt(2),Bar.c,Crot.c(2), Crot.h(2),Plb(2),Sil(2).

II In the same chapter,with different medicines.
Throat : Anaesthesia : Acon(2), All.c(2),Arg.m,Gels(2),,kali.c,Mag.s,Olnd,Verat.v.
Throat : Numbness : Acon, All.c, Arg.m,Gels,, Kali.c,Mag.s,Olnd,Verat.v.
( replaced by )

Stomach :
I. In the same chapter,with the same medicine, but different grading.
Stomach : Disordered,fish : Chin.a.
Stomach : Indigestion,fish after : Chin.a(2).

II. In the same chapter,with different medicines.
Stomach : Disordered,mental exertion : Arn,Calc,Cocc,Lach(2),Nux.m,Nux.v(3),Puls(2),Sullph(2),Verat.
Stomach : Indigestion,mental exertion,after : Arn,Calc,Cocc,Lach(2),Nux.v(3),Puls(2),Sulph(2),Verat.

Stomach : Disordered,vexation,after. : Cham(3),Ip(2).
Stomach : Indigestion,vexation,after : Cham(3),Ip(3),Tarent.

III. In different chapters with different medicines. :
Stomach : Epileptic aura : Art.v, Bell,Bufo, Calc(2),Cic(3), Cupr,Indg(2),Nux.v(3),Sil(2), Sulph(3).
Generalities : Convulsions,epileptic,aura,solar plexus,from : Art.v,Bell,Bufo,
( Difference in grade of Clcarea and addition of Causticum )

Abdomen :
I In different chapters with different medicines.
Abdomen : Epilepsy,begins in : Bufo.
Generalities : Convulsions,begins in the abdomen : Aran,Bufo(2)

Genitalia female :
I. In the same chapter,with the same medicines,but different grading. :

Genetalia female : Aura,extending from uterus to throat : Lach
Generalities,Convulsions,epileptic,aura,uterus to throat: Lach

Larynx and trachea ;
I In different chapters with the same medicines,but different grading :

Larynx and trachea : Supports larynx,on coughing : Acon(2),All.c(3),Ant.t,Bell(2),Dros(2),Hep(2),Iod,Lach.
Cough : Grasping throat during : Acon(2),All.c,Ant.t,Bell,

Cough :
I. In the same chapter with the same medicines in the same grading. :

1. Cough : Paroxysmal,consisting of,three coughs : Carb.v(2),Cupr(2),Phos,Stann.
Cough : Three coughs in succession : Carb.v(20,Cupr(2),Phos,Stann.

Extremities :
I. In different chapters with different medicines. :

Extremities : Wetting feet agg : Cham,Merc,Nat.c(2),Nat.m(2),Phos(2),Puls(2),Rhus.t,Sep(2),Sil(3),Xan.
Generalities: wet getting,feet : Agn,All.c(2), Cham, Dulc(2),Merc,Nat.c,Nat.m,Nux.m(2),Phos(2),Puls(3),

Chill :

I In the same chapter with the same medicines in the same grading:

Chill : Exposure,working in water : Calc(3),Rhus.t(2).
Chill : Water,working in from : Calc(3),Rhus.t(2).

II. In the same chapter with different medicines. :

Chill : Exposure,wet,from becoming : Acon, Aran(2), Bar.c, Bell, Bry(2), Calc(2), Cedr(2),
Dulc(2), Nat.s(2), Rhus.t(3),Sep,Tarent(2).

Chill : Water,from getting wet : Acon,Aran(2),Bar.c,Bell(2),Bry(2), Calc(2), Cedr, Dulc(2), Nat.s(2),Rhus.t(3),Sep(2),Sil.

Rubrics which seem to be included in the generalities chapter
1. Mind : Closing eyes amel
2. Mind : Darkness agg.
3. Head : Uncovering head agg.
4. Head : Warm coverings on head agg.
5. Head : washing head agg.
6. External throat : Clothing agg.
7. External throat : Uncovering throat agg.
8. Stomach : Eructation, aggravate .
9. Stomach : Eructation ,ameliorate.
10. Abdomen : Covering agg.
11. Rectum : Flatus amel.
12. Genetalia,male: Sexual passion,suppressing the,complaints from.
13. Genetalia,female : Menopause.
14. Extremities : Hang down,letting limbs agg.
15. Extremities : Hang down letting limbs amel.
16. Extremities : Hang down letting arms amel.
17. Extremities : Uncovering agg.
18. Extremities : Walk,late learning to.
19. Extremities : Wetting feet agg.
20. Perspiration : Suppressed, commplaints from.
21. Perspiration : Symptoms agg, while sweating.
22. Perspiration : Symptoms amel.
23. Perspiration : Symptoms, after agg.
24. Skin : Eruption,suppressed.

Spelling mistakes : (In reprint edition 1995; mini size.)
1. In main Rubrics :
Eg : Mind : Headless : ( Heedless )
(The meaning of these two words is same.But,it seems to be a mistake,as the cross reference given in the rubric `Careless’ is `Heedless’.)
Eye : Wind look : ( Wild look )
Face : Discoloration of jaws easy : ( Dislocation of jaws easy )
Perspiration : Sports : ( Spots ).

2. In main rubrics,but in repetition :
Eg :Stomach : Page 525. Left top page side heading.
Pulpitation : ( Pulsation )

Mistakes in levels of rubrics.
Examples :1. Larynx and Trachea : Level error from the rubric
Voice,hoarseness,children in to Voice,hoarseness,cold,damp weather.
(All these rubrics are given in the next level of the rubric Voice,hoarseness,calling aloud when )
then Voice,hoarseness,cough during to Voice,hoarseness,mucous in larynx.

(All these are given under Voice,hoarseness,coryza during )and Voice,hoarseness,wet weather agg. ( Given in the next level of hoarseness,warm room )

2. Chill : Error in level of rubric
Chill : Uncovering,aversion to, chilliness from.
(Chilliness from is given at the same level as that of aversion)

3. Stomach : Error in level of rubrics
Stomach,Vomiting,food,eating,5 or 6 hours after to
Stomach,vomiting,food,eating,undigested,2 or 3 hours after.( These rubrics are given under eating, immediately after.)


1. Comments will be moderated. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name, to   avoid rejection.
2. Comments that are abusive, personal, incendiary or irrelevant cannot be published.
3. Please write complete sentences. Do not type comments in all capital letters, or in all   lower case letters, or using abbreviated text. (example: u cannot substitute for you, d is not   'the', n is not 'and')


Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment may take some time to appear.