SYSTEMIC LUPUS ERYTHEMATOSIS
Dr. Bindu.K BHMS,MD(Hom)
IMMUNOPATHOLOGY
There are occasions when the immune system is itself a cause of disease or
other undesirable consequences . The system can fail in one of three ways.
1) Inappropriate reaction to self antigens ; Autoimmunity .
2) Ineffective immune response ; Immunodeficiency .
3) Overactive immune response ; Hypersensitivity.
AUTOIMMUNITY
Normally the immune system recognises all foreign antigens and reacts
against them , while recoganising the body's own tissues as ' self 'and making
no reaction against them. If The system should react against self components,
autoimmune disease occurs .
Ideally, at least three requirement should be, met before a disorder can be
categorised as truly due to autoimmunity,
1. The presence of an autoimmune reaction
2. Clinical or experimental evidence that such a reaction is not secondary to
tissue damage but is of primary pathogenetic significance, and
3. The absence of another well defined cause of the disease.
Unfortunately, these requirements are met only in a few diseases, such as SLE,
and autoimmune blood dyscrasias.
The autoimmune disorder forming spectrum on one end of which are conditions
in which auto antibodies are directed against a single organ or tissue(organ
specific).There fore resulting in localised tissue damage. A classic example is
Hashimoto's thyroiditis, in which the antibodies have absolute specificity for
thyroid constituents. At the other end of the spectrum is SLE, in which a
diversity of antibodies results in wide spread lesions through out the body (non
organ specific).In SLE auto antibodies react with nuclear constituents of
virtually every cell with in the organism. in the middle of the spectrum falls
the Goodpasture's Syndrome, in which antibodies to basement membrane of lung &
kidney induce lesions and symptoms in these organs. It is obvious that
autoimmunity implies loss of self tolerance.
Immunologic Tolerance
Immunology tolerance is a state in which the individual is incapable of
developing an immune response to a specific antigen. Self tolerance refers to
lack of responsiveness to an individual’s antigens, and obviously it underlies
our ability to live in harmony with our own cells and tissues. Several
mechanisms, abbeit not well understood, have been postulated to explain the
tolerant state.
There of these are important.
1. Clonal deletion:- immature Tcell clones with T cell receptors (TCR) that have
high affinity for self antigens are deleted in the thymus during development. A
similar negative selection also occurs during Bcell development. How ewer,
clonal deletion is not perfect,and normal Bcells can be found with surface Ig
against self antigens, (Eg:, DNA, myelin, collagen, and thyroglobulin).
2. Clonal anergy:-this refers to irreversible functional inactivation of
developing T&B cells.One mechanism of clonal anergy is recognition of antigen in
the absence of co-simulatory signals from the antigen presenting cell.
3. Suppression of auto reactive Leucocyte:-components that actively supress
immune responses to self include suppressor T cells and their products,such as
TGF-b1 and IL-10.
Mechanisms of Autoimmune Diseases
The pathogenesis of autoimmunity appears to involve immunologic ,genetic and
viral factors intracting through the complicated mechanisms that are poorly
understood .
Immunologic mechanisms:- Four general mechanisms for loss of self- tolerance
have been postulated.
A. bypass of helper T cell tolerance :- tolerance of CD4 + helper T cell is
critical to the prevention of autoimmunity. Tolerance to a self antigen is often
associated with clonal deletion or anergy of carrier specific helper T cells in
the presence of fully competent hapten specific B cells. Therefore ,tolerance
may be broken if the need for tolerant helper T cells is bypassed or
substituted.
1) Modification of the molecule
if a potentially autoantigenic determined (hapten) is complexed to a new
carrier ,the carrier part of the complex may be recognised by non tolerantT
cells as foreign. The latter would then cooperate with the hapten- specific
Bcells , leading to the production of auto antibodies. This modification of the
molecule could arise in several ways.
-complexing of self antigens with drugs or micro organisms
-partial degradation of autoantigens
2) Molecular mimicry
Several infectious agent cross react with human tissue through their
haptenic determinants (B cell epitomes). The infecting microorganisms may
trigger a antibody response by presenting the cross reacting haptenic
determinant in association with their own carrier ,to which the helper T cells
are not tolerant. Once the infectious agents provoke tissue damage , their
continued presence is not necessary because tissue injury releases more self
antigens .
3) Polyclonal lymphocytic activation
Direct (Tcell independent) polyclonal B cell activation by micro organisms
and their products e.g. bacterial lipo polysaccharide (endotoxin) or Epstein-
Barr virus.
B. Imbalance of supressor-helper T cell function
Loss of supressor T cell has been implicated in the development of auto immunity
in several animal models and is suspected in human auto immune diseases.
Excessive T cell helper may drive B cells to extremely high levels of auto
antibody production
C. Emergence of a sequestered antigen
Any self antigen that is completely sequestered during development is likely
to be viewed as foreign if introduced into the circulation and an immune
response will develop. Spermatozoa , myelin basic protien, and lens crystallin
fall into this category of antigens
HLA linkage (especially to the DR antigens) and familial clustering in some
autoimmune diseases suggest a genetic component. Exogenous infection with
bacteria , mycoplasmas or especially viruses may also trigger autoimmunity,
suggesting an exogenous component as well.
SYSTEMIC LUPUS ERYTHEMATOSIS
Syn: Disseminated lupus
erythematosus
Definition :it is an inflammatory disease of autoimmune nature involving the
connective tissue of several organ systems and associated with a variable
course.
SLE is world wide in
distribution. In india it constitutes 1-2% of the major rheumatological
problems. Females predominate and the male to female proportion being 1-18. The
disease is rare before below the age of 5 years, but children account for 20 %.
More than 60% of cases are between the ages of 30-60. SLE results from a gross
disturbance of immune mechanisms. Normal body constituents are rendered
immunogenic by various damaging factors such as exposure to sunlight infection
tissue injury,drugs or others. Among these, viral infection and drugs top the
the host’s own tissues. Antinuclear antibodies are mainly seen. ANAs are
commonly detected by indirect immunofluorescence. However, ANAs occur in other
autoimmune disorders and in up to 10% of normal individuals, but anit-double
stranded (native) DNA and anti-smith anitgen antibodies strongly suggest SLE.
ANA can not penetrate intact cells. However, nuclei of damaged cells react with
ANA, los their chromatin patterns, and become homogenous LE bodies (hematoxydin
bodies). Phagocytosis of LE bodies by neutrophils or maltrophages in vitroforms
LE cells in up to 70% of patients with SLE.
In addition to ANAs, lupus patients have many other antoantibodies, some
directed against blood elements. (red cells, plate lets, leukocytes) In addition
up to 20% to 40% of patients have antiphospholipid antibodies. Some bind to
cardiolipin antigen giving rise to false - positive VDRL test. Antiphospholipids
antibodies interfere with the formation of prothrombin activator complex in the
process of blood coagulation. In vitro tests may reveal prolonagation of the
coagulation tests such as APTT, and hence these antiphospholipid antibodies are
also knwon as lupus anticoagulant. These so-called lupus anticoagulant actually
exert a procoagulant effect in vivo, causing recurrent vascular thromboses,
miscarriages, and erebral ischemia. Their mechanism of action in vivo is
unknown.
Etiology and pathogenesis
Monozygotic twin concordance (50 to 60%) and familial and HLA clustering
suggest a genetic predispositon. HLA types B8 and DR3 and inherited deficency of
C1, C4 and C2 complement are known to be associated with a higher incidince of
SLE. In addition, exogenous factors such as drug exposure ultraviolet (UV)
irradiation, Virus infections and estrognes are also involved.
Although the actiology is unknown, the pathogensis is thought to involve some
basic defect in the maintenance of self-tolerance with activation of B cells.
This may occur secondary to some combination of
- Heritable defects in the regulation of B cell proliferation.
- Helper T-cell hyper activity.
- Defects in suppressor T cell function.
Morphology
Typical in all tissnes is an acute necrotizing vasulitis with fibrinoid
deposits, involving small arteries and arterides. Ig, DNA, and C3 may be found
within vessel walls. Skin and muscle one most commonly involved. A perivascular
lymphocytic infiltrate is frequently present.
In chronic cases, vessels show a fibrous thickening and duminal narrowing.
Kidney
Involved in virtually all cases of SLE. There are five patterns of lupus
nephritis.
a. Class I. Normal by light, E M, and fluorescence mocroscopy. rare.
b. Class II - Mesangial lupus glomerulo nephitis (GN), present in about 25% of
patients, associated with minimal hematuria or proteinuria. Slight increase in
mesangial matrioc and cells with granular messangial Ig and complement deposits.
c. Class III - Focal proliferative GN; 20% of patients; associated with
recurrent hacmaturia, moduate proteinuria, and occasional mild renal in
sufficiency. Focal and segmental glomerular swelling with endothelial and
mesangial proliferation, neutrophil infiltration and some times fibrinoid
deposits and capillary thromble.
d. Class IV - Diffuse proliterative GN : 35% to 40% of patients, many of whom
are overtly symptomatic, with microscopic to gross hemature a, proteinuria (some
times nephrotic range), hypertension and diminished glomerlar filteration rate.
Most glomeruli show endothelial, mesangial and occasionally epithdial
profilferation. IC deposits are typically subendothelial, and when extensive
form ‘wire loops’. Frequently, there are also tubular changes with granular IC
deposits in basement memberances and interstitial changes. Most severe form of
lupus nephritis, carrying the worst prognosis.
e. Class V - membranous GN, 15% of patients : induces severe proteinaria or
nephrotic syndrome. Diffusely thickened capillary walls similar to idiopathic
membranous GN and characterised by subepithelial IC deposits.
SKIN
Classically, malar erythema, including bridge of nose (‘butterfly rash’)
Also, variable cutaneous lesions from erythema to bullac else where. Sunlight
exacerbates the lessions. Microscopically, there is basal layer degeneration
with dermal - epidermal junction Ig and complement deposits. The dermis shows
variable fibrosis, perivasular mononulear cell infilterates, and vasular
fibrinoid change.
Joints
Typically a nonspecific, nonerosive synovitis. Minimal joint deformity
incontrast to rhenmatoid arthretis.
Central Nervous system (CNS)
Neuropsychiatirc manifestations probably seconday to endothelial injury and
occlusion (antiphospholipid antibodies) or impaired neuronal function.
Serositis
Initially fibrinous with focal vasculitis, fibrinoid neerosis, and edema
progressing to adhesions, possibly oblitearating serosal cavities (ie pere
cardial sac).
Heart : characteristic non bacterial verrcous endocardities (Libman -
Sacks endocanditis) much less frequent with the use of steroids. Typically,
numerous small, wanty vegetations (0.5 to 4mm) occur on the inflow and or
outflow surfactes of the mitral and tricnspid valves. Micro scopically, they are
composed of necrotic dibris, degenerating fibro blasts, in flammatory cells and
fibrinoid material.
An increasing number of younger patients, especially those treated with
corticosteriods, have clinical evidence of cornary artery disease. The
pathgensis of the cornary altherosclerosis is not cleaur.
Spleen
Moderate spleenomegaly with capsular thickening and follicular hyperplasia.
Marked perivascular fibrosis around penicilliary arteries is characteristic,
producing an onion - skin appearance. Ig, c3 and DNA are found with in these
vessels.
Lungs
Pleuritis with pleural effusions, interstitial pneumonitis, and diffuse
fibrosing alvealitis, all probably related to IC deposition.
Clinical Course
SLE presents insidionsly as a systemic, chronic recurrent, febrile
illness with symptoms referable to virtually any tissue, but especially joints,
skin, kidneys and serosal membrones.
Auto antibodies to the matologic components may indue thrombocytoperia,
leukopenia and anemia. The clinical manifestations are protean.
Clinical manifestations
Prevalence in patients
Hematologic
100
Arthritis
90
Skin
85
Fever
83
Fatigue
81
Weight loss
63
Renal
50
Pleurisy
46
Myalgia
33
Pericaritis
25
Crastro intestinal
21
Raynauds phenomenon
20
Central nervous system
20
Occular
15
Peripharal neuropathy
14
Prenumonitis
11
Clinical manifestations Prevalmic in pts (%)
Parotid gland enlargement
8
Liver disease
2
The course of the disease is highly variable, rarely it is fulminant with
death in weeks to months. Sometimes, the disease may cause minimal symptoms (haematuria,
rash) and remit even without treatment. More often, the disease is characterised
by recurent flares and remissions over many years and is held in check by
immunosuppressive regimens.
Ten - year survival is approximately 70%, death is most commonly caused by
renal failure or intercurrent infections pregnancy is associated with risks to
mother & father.
Discod lupus (DLE):
A disease limited to certaneous lesions that grossly and microscopically
mimic SLE. only 35% of patients have a positive ANA. The lesions show scaling,
atrophy, telengiectasia and Keratotic plugging. They heal with considerable
scarring.
In contrast to SLE, only lesional skin has deposits of Ig complement in the
basal membrance. After many years, 5 to 10% of affected individuals develop
systemic manifestations.
Drug - Induced LE
Drugs such as hydralazine, procainamide, isonizid and D-pencillamine
frequently induce a positive ANA, less often an LE like syndrome with the
latter, although there is multiorgan involvement, renal and CNS disease is an
common. Anti double stranded DNA antibodies are rare, but anithistone antiboides
are common. There is linkage with HLA - DR4. Drug related LE usually remits
after cessation of the offering agent.
Laboratory Investigations
SLE gives rise to an array of abnormalities, some being specific and the
other nonspecific. The nonspecific features include, markedly elevated ESR
(above 100mm/1st h.), moderate anemia, leukopania, thromboc- ytopenia, and
moderate to severe proteinuria. The specific tests depend upon the immunological
abnormalities and they are discribed as follwos.
Serolouical abnormalities in SLE
The antinuclear antibodies (ANA) :- They occur in over 95% of cases. These
are composed of antibodies against DNA single strand, DNA double strand RNA and
several other nuclear components. LE cell phenomenon is due to antinuclear
antibodies.
Other immunological markers which are nonspecific are anticytoplasmic
antibodies, lymphocytoxins, antibodies against R.B.C, W B.C and platelets,
circulating anticoagulants, antithyroid and other organ specific antibodies,
rehumatoid factor, flase positive wassermann reaction and VDRL, cryoglobulins,
and circulating immune complexes. Levels of complements C3 and C4 are reduced.
Presence of antinuclear antibodies and demonstration of LE
cells should make the diagnosis reasonably certain.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis of SLE should be suspected if there are febrile episodes with
multisystem involvement and high ESR, not responding to general line of
treatment. The American rheumatism Association (ARA) has laid down criteria for
diagnosis of SLE. These help to distinguish SLE from the other reheumatic
disorders. The important criteria are facial rash, discoid lupus, Ranand’s
phenomenon alopecia, Photsensitivity, Oral and rasophaynaged uleeration,
artlaitis, neuropsychiatiric manifestions and laboratory features.
Management
Since there are no curative measures, the main aim is to induce remission
and prevent relapses. General management consists of avoidance of direct sun
light and offending drugs and prompt attention to complications.
References
1. Basic pathology by Kumar, Cotrans, Robbins
2. Boyd’s textbook of pathology
3. Davidson’s Principles and practice of medicine
4. Harrison’s internal medicine
|